Top Private Schools Near Long Island’s Luxury Neighborhoods in 2025

by Kim Faines

Top-Rated Private Schools Near Long Island's Luxury Neighborhoods

For families seeking luxury homes in Nassau and Suffolk Counties, access to top-rated private schools is a key factor in their home-buying decision. Long Island is home to some of the most prestigious private schools in the country, offering exceptional academics, robust extracurricular programs, and supportive communities that prepare students for success at elite colleges and universities. In 2025, the demand for homes near these top schools continues to rise as families prioritize convenience, quality education, and a well-rounded student experience. This guide outlines the leading private schools near Long Island’s upscale neighborhoods and key factors to consider when selecting the right school for your family.

Benefits of Private Schools in Long Island’s Luxury Areas

Academic Excellence

Private schools on Long Island are renowned for their academic rigor and individualized instruction.

Small Class Sizes: Students receive personalized attention, allowing teachers to tailor lessons to individual learning styles.
Advanced Placement (AP) and International Baccalaureate (IB) Programs: Many institutions offer advanced courses that prepare students for the demands of college academics.
Dedicated College Counseling: Students benefit from dedicated guidance counselors who assist with college applications, scholarships, and academic goal-setting.

Enriched Extracurricular Programs

A hallmark of Long Island’s private schools is their emphasis on holistic development.

Competitive Athletics: Many schools boast championship sports teams, state-of-the-art fitness centers, and sprawling sports fields.
Performing Arts: Students have opportunities to participate in theater productions, music ensembles, and visual arts showcases.
STEM and Innovation: Robotics clubs, science fairs, and coding classes foster creativity and problem-solving skills.

Character Development and Community

Private schools prioritize leadership development, social responsibility, and emotional intelligence.

Community Service: Many schools require students to complete service projects, fostering a sense of empathy and civic engagement.
Diverse Clubs: From debate teams to environmental clubs, private schools offer organizations that promote collaboration and critical thinking.

Top Private Schools in Nassau County

The Green Vale School (Old Brookville)

Grades: Nursery through 8th grade.
Highlights: Known for its focus on STEAM (science, technology, engineering, arts, and math) and personalized instruction.
Campus Features: Modern science labs, art studios, and outdoor learning spaces enhance the student experience.

Friends Academy (Locust Valley)

Grades: Pre-K through 12th grade.
Highlights: A Quaker school with a commitment to inclusivity, academic rigor, and service learning.
Unique Offerings: Emphasizes values such as simplicity, peace, and community.

Portledge School (Locust Valley)

Grades: Pre-K through 12th grade.
Highlights: Offers a robust International Baccalaureate (IB) program and a thriving arts program.
Facilities: Features include a state-of-the-art theater, athletic complex, and collaborative learning spaces.

St. Mary’s High School (Manhasset)

Grades: 9th through 12th grade.
Highlights: Known for its Catholic tradition, academic excellence, and emphasis on moral development.
Extracurriculars: Offers competitive sports teams, faith-based service opportunities, and leadership programs.

Top Private Schools in Suffolk County

The Knox School (St. James)

Grades: 6th through 12th grade.
Highlights: A college preparatory school with a global curriculum and focus on leadership development.
Unique Feature: Offers boarding and day programs, making it popular among international families.

Ross School (East Hampton)

Grades: Pre-K through 12th grade.
Highlights: Known for its progressive, interdisciplinary curriculum that emphasizes global studies, wellness, and arts.
Campus: Includes a beautiful outdoor amphitheater, wellness center, and sustainability initiatives.

Stony Brook School (Stony Brook)

Grades: 7th through 12th grade.
Highlights: A Christian preparatory school known for academic excellence, character development, and faith-based education.
Traditions: Includes time-honored traditions such as community chapels, student mentoring, and honor societies.

Harbor Country Day School (St. James)

Grades: Pre-K through 8th grade.
Highlights: Provides individualized attention, STEAM initiatives, and an inclusive environment.
Enrichment Programs: Offers classes in robotics, theater, and creative writing.

Private Schools Near Long Island’s Luxury Neighborhoods

Great Neck and Manhasset (North Shore)

Luxury neighborhoods like Great Neck and Manhasset are known for their proximity to top-rated private schools, including St. Mary’s High School and Friends Academy. These areas feature stunning estates and convenient access to cultural attractions.

Old Westbury and Sands Point (Gold Coast)

The Gold Coast neighborhoods of Old Westbury and Sands Point are minutes from prestigious institutions like Green Vale School and Portledge School. Families in these communities enjoy sprawling properties with exceptional amenities.

The Hamptons (South Shore)

East Hampton, Southampton, and Shelter Island are popular among affluent families who prioritize education and lifestyle. The Ross School’s emphasis on sustainability, global studies, and creative learning makes it a standout choice.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Private School

Academic Programs

Consider whether the school’s curriculum aligns with your child’s goals.

Unique Offerings: Some schools specialize in STEM programs, performing arts, or language immersion.
College Preparation: Schools often publish data on college acceptance rates and alumni achievements.

Location and Commute

The school’s location can impact daily routines. Dream Select Realty helps families find homes near their preferred schools for convenience and reduced travel time.

Tuition and Financial Aid

Private school tuition can range from $20,000 to over $60,000 per year. Many schools offer financial aid and scholarships.

Tuition Assistance: Families should inquire about need-based financial aid and merit scholarships.

Extracurricular Opportunities

Evaluate whether the school provides programs that match your child’s interests.

Athletic Programs: Consider whether the school has varsity sports, intramurals, or specialized sports clinics.
Arts and Clubs: Look for theater programs, debate teams, and science clubs.

The Role of Dream Select Realty

Dream Select Realty understands the importance of education in the home-buying process. Our team helps families identify luxury properties near top private schools, ensuring that their lifestyle and educational priorities align seamlessly.

Comprehensive Support

Neighborhood Insights: We provide detailed information about local school districts and private institutions.
School Tours: We can coordinate school visits and private tours to help families make informed decisions.
Resale Value Analysis: Homes near top-rated schools tend to have higher resale values and attract competitive offers.

Tips for Families Moving to Long Island

Visit Schools in Person: Touring campuses and meeting faculty can provide valuable insight into the school’s culture and community.
Understand Admission Requirements: Some private schools require entrance exams, interviews, and recommendation letters.
Plan Early: Private schools have limited spots and strict application deadlines, so early planning is crucial.
Consider Long-Term Plans: Homes near top-rated private schools are not only convenient but also retain strong resale value.